Greetings from Storrs,
Connecticut, where, as I write, we are just entering mud season.
Springtime seems like an impossibly distant horizon, but by the time
you read this I expect it will be upon us all. If you have never
experienced spring in the northeast after a long winter, you really
need to try it sometime (Californians, just keep quiet).
The annual meeting in
Phoenix was fabulous, as usual. I can't say the city was thrilling,
but the venue was excellent, attendance fantastic and the company
endlessly entertaining. The presence of huge swarms of graduate
students decimating hors d'oeuvre trays like locusts in a
cornfield was especially gratifying. Can graduate students reproduce
asexually? It seemed like their numbers doubled just during the few
days of the meeting... In any case, it is a propitious sign
suggesting we are doing something right and that the society's
future is in good (if hungry) hands.
The quality of the
papers, posters and symposia seemed to me to be especially high this
year, but then I think that every year. As usual, there was too much
to see and too many conflicts among sessions. For example, there were
at least three papers scheduled opposite my own that I would much
rather have attended. Annoying as it is, choice is a good thing and
again speaks to the vibrancy of the meetings. One change we will be
trying at the next (San Antonio) meeting, following Dave Carrier's
suggestion, is to group the student Davis Prize competitors into a
single paper session with as little DVM conflict as possible. This
will elevate the competition to a special event and encourage as many
of us as possible to attend. It will also make it possible for us to
announce the winner of the prize at the business meeting.
When I took this job I
was assured that it was all glory and prestige, no work (work is for
the Program Officer and the Secretary). While I cannot deny that the
aura of the office surrounds me like a golden glow and that students
and faculty, alike, pay homage by moving aside as I approach (they
say it is to avoid me, but I know better), I have found myself
grappling unexpectedly with several pesky work-type issues, namely,
budget and bylaws. Taking the latter first, you will be asked to vote
on a change of the DVM bylaws related to the D. Dwight Davis student
prize (see the proposed bylaws changes section of the newsletter,
below). These changes were suggested by David Carrier (2005 and 2006
Davis Prize Committee Chair) and discussed at the January 2006
business meeting. An online forum for membership discussion was also
available. Former Chair, Beth Brainerd, has proposed a revised text.
In short, the change limits student competition for the prize to two
times. This will encourage students to compete only when their
projects are more complete and polished. As noted above, it will
further allow us to group all the competing papers into a special,
unopposed paper session, making it a celebration of our student
members. I hope you will support this change.
In addition, we are
currently working on several other small changes to the bylaws
initiated by Beth Brainerd. These are designed to streamline the
election process of electing DVM officers and to improve their
interactions. For one thing, a new position of 'Past Chair' is
being proposed for addition to the DVM Executive Committee (along
with Chair, Secretary and Program Officer). This formalizes the
status of the former Chair who is a de facto advisor to the
current officers (why do I have the nagging suspicion that as soon as
I become 'Past Chair' the position will be dissolved...). Details
of these changes will be presented to the membership later this year,
discussed at the next business meeting and subsequently voted on.
They are not at issue right now. I just wanted you to know that we
actually do stuff.
Second, the SICB budget
is undergoing some growing pains as we change from a calendar to a
standard (June-July) fiscal year. This is the transition year and
there are some kinks to be worked out. However, a more important
issue is that for the first time since the bad-old-days when the
Society nearly collapsed fiscally, we will start to run a deficit.
There is no cause for alarm because the Society is financially very
healthy, but it means that spending is going to have to be curtailed
sooner rather than later because we cannot afford to run a deficit
for more than a couple of years (I know, I've tried it). The SICB
Executive Committee has been charged with examining the budget and
identifying areas that can be controlled. Two of the biggest budget
items are graduate student support and annual meeting expenses.
Although no one was happy about it, the Executive Committee agreed
almost unanimously that grad support has to be capped. This will take
the form of limiting student support for travel and rooms at annual
meetings to a maximum of three years (and possibly a slightly higher
co-payment, depending on the year). Spending on graduate student
support for meetings has been growing steeply for many years with no
sign of a plateau, so it was felt that capping it was critical before
it overwhelmed the budget. The second noticeable impact of the budget
caps is that we can expect less lavish food spreads at society
functions during future annual meetings. Budgets for food at both
society-wide and divisional socials will be capped at amounts
slightly less than we are used to, so look forward to more chips and
salsa, less roasted asparagus. Hotels charge egregious amounts of
money for catered food, so this is not a trivial thing.
Although spending caps
are not ideal, I hope you will agree that SICB generally and DVM
specifically remains an extremely generous supporter of student
members (our future, after all) in all respects. The Executive
Committee and Financial Committees are looking for other ways to save
money and increase income, and despite these limits, the future of
the Society looks rosy. Please feel free to contact me with comments
or questions (kurt.schwenk@uconn.edu).
Have a great spring and summer.
I'd like to start by
thanking whatever committee was charged with scheduling the site of
this year's meeting. The weather, food and hotel/conference center
were great! Not surprisingly, the meeting was good fun as well, and I
trust all of you enjoyed the talks, posters and informal
conversations about science. Now onto the business at hand...
DVM Business Meeting
Notes (1/5/2007)
Announcements:
The Society's
officers stopped by to introduce themselves and remind us that the
Society's journal, Integrative and Comparative Biology, is
in good shape, with a nice new format and speedy online publishing
of new papers. Melina Hale confirmed that the journal is not on
PubMed yet and also clarified that the journal has the right of 1st
refusal for papers based on society symposia.
Tony Russell told
us of the upcoming International Congress of Vertebrate Morphology
(ICVM) in Paris this summer. In addition, as the president of the
Canadian Society of Zoologists, he clued us in to the
"morphology-friendly" environment of that society and offered a
standing invitation to attend their annual meetings (in Montreal in
2007)
I announced that
the society is in the process of retooling its website and that your
pictures, videos, flash animations etc. would make excellent
additions to the DVM page. Please send any such materials to me
(ggillis@mtholyoke.edu)
and you'll be hearing from me if I don't hear from you.
Jeff Walker listed
the symposia for next year (see Jeff's report above). He also
announced that the deadline for submitting ideas for symposia for
the 2009 meeting in Boston is August '07. Email Jeff with your
ideas (walker@maine.edu).
Adam Summers
apologized for any problems people had with student rooming issues,
but was pleased to report that 361 students were supported with
rooms at this year's meeting and 30 students had their
registrations waived. In addition, this year $23,000 was given to
students in the form of grants-in-aid-of-research, and $8,000 in the
form of travel grants.
Bill Zamer from
NSF shared his thoughts on some of the changes in IOB at NSF. Many
of us likely fall under the umbrella of the Physiological and
Structural Systems Cluster in the Division of Integrated Organismal
Systems. He suggested that "systems-based approaches" were
important in our applications for NSF grants and encouraged us to
have a look at Jim Collins' presentation on integrative biology in
the early 21st century (go to the Phoenix meeting link on
the SICB website to view the presentation).
Beth Brainerd
announced that Mark Westneat and Sharon Swartz are up for election
to Chair-Elect this spring (see below for their abbreviated cv's
and statements). In addition, Beth announced that the tradition of
giving a book prize to the D. Dwight Davis award winner has been
restored, and this year it is a copy of O.C. Marsh's 1880
monograph on extinct toothed-birds of North America.
Much of the remaining
part of the meeting was spent discussing the issue of identity for
DVM in the context of the newly formed Division of Comparative
Biomechanics. Several members expressed potential concern about DVM
membership and session attendance (which will be monitored closely in
coming years), and it was made clear that careful planning of the
timing of business meetings between the various Divisions that
attract our membership is essential. In the end, most of us still
consider DVM as our home-base and thus it will surely remain a vital
division.
As the final order of
business, Beth passed the reins (reign) of Division chair onto Kurt
Schwenk, the self-professed "bald guy that's not Ken Dial" who
quickly inspired us with his visions as the new "commander". On
a serious note, Kurt did announce that he is on the editorial staff
at the Journal of Experimental Zoology A, and that they are excited
to receive interesting work in the field of functional vertebrate
morphology. Please see the final section of this newsletter for more
detail.
2007 Student Award
Winners
Davis Award(Tie) | Davis Award (Tie) | Poster Award |
Diego Sustaita | Cally Harper | Nathan Bird |
| | |
At this year's
meeting, the excellence of our student speakers was reflected in a
shared D. Dwight Davis award. Both Diego Sustaita (University of
Connecticut) and Cally Harper (UNC Wilmington) were recognized for
their important contributions to vertebrate morphology. Diego's
talk, coauthored with Fritz Hertel (Cal. State Northridge), was
entitled "Bite and grip performance in relation to killing behavior
of North American accipiters and falcons". In it, he showed that
differences in actual bite and grip performances among these birds
complemented previous musculoskeletal morphological analyses, and
that such differences reflect distinct predatory strategies in which
falcons use their beaks to deliver powerful bites to kill prey
whereas accipiters rely on their feet and tightly gripped talons and
toes (I think I win the award for longest sentence in the
newsletter...). Diego's future work will involve studying feeding
performance in shrikes in relation to their morphological and
ecological variation. Cally's talk, coauthored with a number of
colleagues from Wilmington, was entitled "The gross morphology and
fiber architecture of the melon in bottlenose dolphins, Tursiops
truncatus". According to Cally, the melon is a specialized
lipid structure that lies within the dolphin forehead and functions
in the transmission of echolocation sounds. Her work involves
analyzing fibrous networks throughout the melon and their associated
connections to muscles and surrounding blubber. In particular, her
work explores how dolphins might use facial muscles to alter the
shape and internal pressure of the melon, which in turn could affect
sound propagation. This work fits nicely within the context of her
larger goals of understanding better the evolution of water-based
communication mechanisms in vertebrates in relation to cranial
morphology.
Nathan Bird, of George
Washington University, was awarded the DVM poster prize at this
year's meeting. His poster, co-authored with Pat Hernandez (also
of GWU), was entitled "Morphological variation of the Weberian
apparatus in cypriniform fishes". In it he showed that structural
components of the apparatus that are directly involved with hearing
(i.e., the ossicles themselves) exhibit very little morphological
variation whereas accessory structures such as ribs and neural arches
exhibit considerably more variability. Nathan is also using
zebrafish to study genes involved in the development of the Weberian
apparatus and eventually hopes to understand the genetic bases of
evolutionary change in this novel and complex morphological
structure.
Congratulations once
again to our award winners and all the other DVM students who
consistently present excellent work at the SICB meetings!
Message
from the Student/Postdoc Representative
Russ Main
The 2007 SICB meeting
in Phoenix was another success in regards to the events and programs
organized by the Student and Post-doc Affairs committee. The
Graduate Student and Post-doc Orientation was very well attended yet
again, with around 300 people on hand to hear presentations
concerning how to make the most of the meeting's academic and
social events. This year's SPDAC workshop entitled "What Editors
Want" took place on the last night of the meeting and was attended
by about 200 students and post-docs. Editors from various journals
representing the different divisions of SICB discussed what types of
research their journals cover and the submission and publication
process. The editors' presentations and the question and answer
session were insightful and appreciated by those in attendance.
Thank you to those members of DVM who participated in the workshop.
Lastly, if there are
graduate student or post-doctoral members of DVM who wish to
volunteer to participate in planning and organizing SPDAC events,
please send me an e-mail (rpm74@cornell.edu) and I will notify the
SPDAC committee chair of your interest.
Proposed
Bylaws change for D. Dwight Davis Award
As many of you probably
remember, at the Orlando business meeting there was much discussion
of changing some of our current bylaws for the D. Dwight Davis award.
Specifically, the chair of the awards committee that year, Dave
Carrier, suggested that students be limited in the number of times
they compete for the award. An important motivation for this was
judging quality. Judges are overwhelmed by the number of
presentations they need to evaluate (~ 40 in a given year), and many
presentations are of preliminary work. If students are limited to
competing only two times, this will reduce the load on judges,
allowing them to put more time/thought into their evaluations. In
addition, having fewer student talks will allow us to have a single
"student session" at the meeting with minimal conflicts, allowing
us all to see the work of our Division's amazing students. Below
is the actual text of the current and proposed bylaws regarding the
Davis Award. Please participate in the online vote!
CURRENT
Article XV. Student Award - D. Dwight Davis Award
1. From the D. Dwight Davis fund of the Division a $100.00 prize may
be given for an outstanding paper presented by a student (or by a new
Ph.D. who received the degree no more than 12 months before the
meeting at which the paper is presented). In addition, a certificate
will be given as well as an appropriate gift to reflect Vertebrate
Morphology. The work must be original, and must have been carried out
by the student or students. The award is made only on the unanimous
decision of a committee of three appointed before the meeting by the
Chair of the Division. The guidelines for the award are as follows:
a. The intention of the award is to recognize significant conceptual,
observational, and experimental contributions to he field of
vertebrate morphology. These shall be the major criteria for
selection. Only outstanding work is to be recognized.
b. Acceptable standards of visual aids and oral presentation shall be
required for consideration. Spectacular presentation techniques shall
not by themselves qualify a paper.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PROPOSED NEW
Article XV. Student Award - D. Dwight Davis Award
1. From the D. Dwight Davis fund of the Division a $100.00 prize may
be given for an outstanding paper presented by a student (or by a new
Ph.D. who received the degree no more than 12 months before the
meeting at which the paper is presented). The award is made only on
the unanimous decision of a committee of at least three members,
appointed before the meeting by the Chair of the Division. The
guidelines for the award are as follows:
a. Each student shall be allowed to compete for
the D. Dwight Davis Award no more than two times.
b. The work must be original, must have been carried out by the
competing student, and the student must be the first author.
Co-authored papers may be entered into the competition, but the
student must describe explicitly the contributions of all of the
co-authors as part of the presentation. Failure to make the
contributions of all listed co-authors clear may be grounds for
disqualification.
c. The intention of the award is to recognize significant conceptual,
observational, and experimental contributions to the field of
vertebrate morphology. These shall be the major criteria for
selection. Only outstanding work is to be recognized.
d. Acceptable standards of visual aids and oral presentation shall be
required for consideration. Spectacular presentation techniques shall
not by themselves qualify a paper.
Elections:
Candidates for DVM Chair-Elect
SHARON SWARTZ, PhD
Current Position:
Associate Professor of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology and
Engineering, Brown University
Education:
Ph.D. 1988: The
University of Chicago
B.A. 1981: Oberlin
College (High Honors).
Professional
Experience:
1996-2007:
Associate Professor, EEB and Engineering, Brown University
1990-1996:
Assistant Professor, EEB and Engineering, Brown University
1987-1990:
Assistant Professor of Cell Biology & Anatomy, School of
Medicine, and Anthropology, College of Arts and Sciences and Graduate
School, Northwestern University.
Awards and
Honors:
2000: Dean's
Excellence in Teaching Award, Brown Medical School
1999: Hooder, Brown
University School of Medicine
1999: Winner,
American Medical Women's Association Gender Equity Award
1995-1999: Marshall,
Brown University School of Medicine Commencement Exercises
1995: Nominee,
American Medical Women's Association Gender Equity Award
1992: Mary
Putnam-Jacobi Award for the Outstanding Woman Medical Faculty Member,
Brown Women in Medicine
1986: Harper
Memorial Doctoral Fellowship, The University of Chicago
1982-1985: Searle
Graduate Fellow, The University of Chicago
1981: graduation
with High Honors in Biology, Oberlin College
1980: Sigma Xi, Phi
Beta Kappa
SICB Activities:
I have been a DVM member since 1982, and since that time have chaired
numerous contributed paper sessions and served several times on the
Student Awards Committee and Nominating Committee. I have
participated in the Northeast Regional DVM Meetings since their
inception in 1991, and have hosted or co-hosted Regional DVM Meetings
at Brown three times since then.
Other
Memberships: International Society of Vertebrate Morphology;
American Society for Biomechanics, American Physical Society ñ
Division of Fluid Dynamics, North American Symposium on Bat Research.
Research
Interests: Evolutionary and functional morphology of mammalian
locomotor systems; biomechanics of animal flight; comparative
biomechanics of vertebrate skin and bone; size and scale issues in
biological structure; novel visualization approaches for complex data
Statement of
Goals: Our discipline - if it is, indeed, a discipline! - is
transforming at an astonishing rate. As I recently told a new
graduate student in an unrelated field, very few of my present
research activities would have been even imaginable to me when, as an
undergraduate, I made a decision to pursue a career with vertebrate
morphology at its center. On the other hand, below the surface of
immense technological change, we retain deep connections to our
historical roots; many of the kinds of questions that have driven
students of vertebrate form for decades remain vital, even as the
details of how we try to answer our questions may change. The study
of morphology will continue to become more multidisciplinary; it
takes no seer to predict that interconnections of morphology to
physiology, systematics, evo-devo, biomechanics, and biochemistry
will continue to grow, and engineers, computer scientists,
mathematicians, and others will become more and more familiar
contributors at our meetings and in our journals. The recent creation
of a SICB Division of Comparative Biomechanics is one striking - and,
to me, very exciting - hallmark of these trends, as are the
increasing prominence of interdisciplinary funding initiatives (e.g.
Frontiers in Integrative Biological Research, Assembling the Tree
of Life, and the National Evolutionary Synthesis Center, all through
NSF). Over the next ten years, vertebrate morphology faces important
challenges that arise from this juxtaposition of rapid change and
commitment to the traditional core of morphological study, and the
DVM should, I believe, play a critical role at this key moment in our
scientific `ontogeny'. We must chart a course that enhances the links
between vertebrate morphology and other growing disciplines without
sacrificing the unique character of our field; that supports our
graduate students and young faculty and continues to attract
wonderful new scientific talent; and that focuses our vision at
regional, national and international levels. As a single individual,
I could not hope to effectively meet these challenges; as Division
chair, I would be honored to integrate, motivate, and inspire our
members to work together for the DVM community.
MARK WESTNEAT
Current
Position: Curator of Zoology (Fishes), Field Museum of Natural
History, Chicago
Education:
Ph.
D. 1990. Duke University.
B.
A. 1984. The College of Wooster, Ohio.
Professional
Experience:
1997-2006:
Associate Curator of Zoology, Field Museum of Natural History.
1992-1997:
Assistant Curator of Zoology, Field Museum of Natural History.
1992-
2007: Lecturer, Department of Organismal Biology and Anatomy and
Committee on Evolutionary Biology, University of Chicago.
1990-1991:
Postdoctoral Research Associate: Department of Neurobiology and
Psychology, Duke University.
Awards
and Honors:
1990:
D. Dwight Davis Award for Best Paper in Vertebrate Morphology:
Division of Vertebrate Morphology, American Society of Zoologists.
1989:
Cocos Foundation Training Grant in Morphology. Duke University.
1988:
Raney Award in Ichthyology, American Society of Ichthyologists and
Herpetologists.
1987:
Stoye Award for Best Student Paper in Genetics, Development, and
Morphology: American Society of Ichthyologists and Herpetologists.
1984-1988:
Graduate Student Teaching Assistantship, Duke University.
1984:
C.G. Bookhout Scholarship: Duke University Marine Laboratory.
SICB
Activities:
Program
Officer, Division of Vertebrate Morphology, American Society of
Zoologists, 1994-96.
Nominating
Committee, Division of Vertebrate Morphology, SICB 1999-2000.
Local
Committee, Chicago 2001, organized SICB social at Field Museum of
Natural History
Research
Interests:
1.
Phylogenetic systematics and evolution of fishes: molecular and
morphological evolution, evolutionary biomechanics, and phylogeny of
diverse marine fish families.
2.
Biomechanics and physiology: behavior, muscle physiology and
neuromotor patterns of feeding, respiration and locomotion in
organisms ranging from insects to fishes to mammals.
3.
Modeling of musculoskeletal systems: mechanical design, muscle
models and computer modeling in biomechanics.
Other
Memberships:
American
Association for the Advancement of Science, American Society of
Ichthyologists and Herpetologists, International Association of
Vertebrate Morphologists, Neotropical Ichthyological Association,
Sigma Xi, Society of Systematic Biologists
Goals
as President-Elect:
It
is an honor to be nominated to be DVM Chair (a.k.a. DVM Commander,
according to Kurt!). The central issue for DVM in the next few years
will be to assess the impact of the new Division of Comparative
Biomechanics on our membership numbers and the health of our science
at the annual meetings. I am deeply interested in this dynamic,
because DVM will always be my home base in SICB. It is where I grew
up, and I know that many of you feel the same way. On the other
hand, what a great thing to have a home for biomechanics, and I will
list that on my name tag too (second, of course, after DVM). I
propose that we take the following actions to keep DVM vibrant and
also take advantage of integration with DCB. First, I want to
monitor the data on DVM member and abstract numbers so that we know
if there is a problem at home in DVM. Second, we should try to
reenergize some of the formerly more active areas of DVM such as
classical comparative and evolutionary morphology, explore the
recruitment of members in other fields such as biological
anthropology and build stronger ties with Developmental Biology.
Third, we should embrace Biomechanics with joint symposia and
sessions on vertebrate function that highlight the I in SICB. DVM
will stay strong and flourish because our science is compelling and
SICB is the best scientific meeting of the year, every year.
Publishing
opportunity
As mentioned at the
Phoenix business meeting, I want to call members' attention to the
new editorial leadership and direction of the Journal of Experimental
Zoology A (Ecological Genetics and Physiology). Günter Wagner is
the new Editor-in-Chief and I am one of the Associate Editors. We are
soliciting high quality submissions of all sorts, but especially want
to encourage the morphological community to consider the journal. The
work does not need to be explicitly experimental, despite the title,
and we are happy to consider review and perspective pieces, as well
as original research. If you have an idea for a paper or want
additional information, feel free to contact me. I will also be
approaching some of you to solicit papers. All submissions are
handled electronically, turnover is fast and one full page of color
is free (as many figures as can fit!). The journal is very widely
indexed and available electronically. -Kurt Schwenk
Link to officer list on DVM page